Vote recordedA promise has just been tested in the States.
CorrectionA verdict has been revised, with the reason why.
RankingsThe leaderboard has moved after today’s sitting.
Guernsey · Promises vs votes · 2025 to 2029 term
Words vs. votes
Every promise States Deputies made in their 2025 election manifestos, set against how they have actually voted in the States of Deliberation. Where no recorded vote bears on a promise, we assess delivery against the public record.
As featured in
The term so far
Updated after every States sitting
Deputies tracked
38
Manifesto promises
777
Recorded votes
317
Tested by a recorded vote
360 of 777
Of the 360 promises tested by a vote334 kept (92.7%)
The overall ranking weighs promises kept against broken promises, abstentions on promise votes and poor attendance in the States, among deputies with enough of a voting record to rank; thinner records follow. Each deputy’s page has the promise-by-promise record with the votes behind every verdict. Full methodology.
Tax Reform - Direction
First half of term
On track
Tax Reform - ImplementationSecond half of termOn track
Maximising Potential in States' Assets (including Leale's Yard)First half of termOn track
Early Years and Family FrameworkFirst half of termBehind schedule
Strategic Workforce PlanningAcross the termBehind schedule
Digital Strategy - Improving Digital MaturityAcross the termBehind schedule
Amendments to the Data Protection LawFirst half of termSeverely behind
Artificial Intelligence Strategy - Understanding Island ImpactFirst half of termSeverely behind
Bailiwick CommissionFirst half of termSeverely behind
UK-EU Reset - Bailiwick ResponseFirst half of termSeverely behind
Review of Population PolicyAcross the termBehind schedule
Reviewing the System and Funding Model for Health and CareAcross the termOn trackReview of the Secondary Healthcare ContractFirst half of termBehind scheduleReview of Medicines Management and PharmacyFirst half of termBehind schedulePrimary Care ReviewSecond half of termOn trackHealth and Care RegulationAcross the termOn trackNew Health Improvement Initiatives - Driven by Population DataAcross the termBehind scheduleAddressing Wider Determinants of HealthAcross the termBehind scheduleReviewing and Resolving the System and Funding Model for Long-Term CareFirst half of term · Partner committeeBehind schedule
Future Harbour RequirementsAcross the termOn trackStrategic Infrastructure PlanFirst half of termBehind scheduleMarine Spatial PlanFirst half of termBehind scheduleGDA Funding and Land Transfer PortfolioFirst half of termSeverely behindPathway to Net Zero and States DecarbonisationAcross the termOn trackEnergy Regulatory FrameworkFirst half of termBehind scheduleOffshore Wind Project - Next StepsFirst half of termOn trackImplementation of the Electricity StrategyAcross the termOn trackClimate Change AdaptationAcross the termOn track
Guernsey Housing Plan - Housing SupplyAcross the termOn trackMaximising Potential in States' Assets (including Leale's Yard)First half of term · Partner committeeOn track
Updated Economic Development StrategyAcross the termOn trackFinance Sector Policy FrameworkFirst half of termOn trackDigital FrameworkAcross the termOn trackFuture Air and Sea Links PolicyFirst half of termBehind scheduleTrade LinksAcross the termOn track
Conclude Work to Determine Governance Model Supporting EducationFirst half of termBehind schedulePrimary Education ReviewSecond half of termOn trackHigher Education Funding ReviewFirst half of termBehind scheduleCulture, Leisure and Heritage StrategySecond half of termOn trackEarly Years and Family FrameworkFirst half of term · Partner committeeBehind schedule
Future Harbour RequirementsAcross the term · Partner committeeOn trackImplementation of the Electricity StrategyAcross the term · Partner committeeOn track
Maximising Potential in States' Assets (including Leale's Yard)First half of term · Partner committeeOn trackMarine Spatial PlanFirst half of term · Partner committeeBehind schedule
Complete the Implementation of the Discrimination Ordinance and CRPD
First half of term
On track
Implementation of the Agreed Changes to the Long-Term Care Insurance SchemeFirst half of termOn track
Reviewing and Resolving the System and Funding Model for Long-Term CareFirst half of term · Partner committeeBehind schedule
Justice Action Plan - Prioritised Actions
Across the term
Behind schedule
Cyber Security and Online SafetyAcross the termBehind schedule
Automated Electoral RollFirst half of termSeverely behind
Review of Civil Contingencies LegislationSecond half of termOn track
Top of the Rocks
In a bid to showcase the best of the Channel Islands, and to mark the imminent launch of the Jersey edition of the scorecard, we’re launching Top of the Rocks: islanders from across the Channel Islands can vote for their favourite political soundbite of the term.
Jersey
“We have assumed for too long that there is always a bag of money down the back of the sofa which will bail us out.”
on the contradiction of supporting an amendment losing £22 million while sitting on the Health Committee, during the Tax Reform debate
1 vote (17%)
Guernsey
“I am not talking here just about ensuring that we produce children so they can be these little fiscal sausages that go through the machine of society. (Laughter) But if we genuinely care about the future of this Island we have to do something radical.”
on returning to the Education, Sport & Culture Committee and supporting the new school governance model
0 votes (0%)
Jersey
“I am going to start my series of contributions by switching on a turntable and placing a broken record on it because I will be making a point that I fear I will need to repeatedly return to throughout the course of this week.”
“I must however question why we continue to go to the Rolls Royce shop to buy a car. We could in fact go to the Mini shop to buy a car, or even better still we could review our need to buy a car and buy a bicycle, or even better walk and save the funds for a greater need.”
on the Tax Reform debate, remarking on the slow pace of proceedings
0 votes (0%)
Guernsey
“That’s Facebook for you. If you are born on Facebook, you die on Facebook. Even though I have sympathy for him, I remember him doing very well out of Facebook.”
Question Time, on alternative uses of Philip Le Feuvre House
0 votes (0%)
Guernsey
“We first met supporting a group of teenagers through the Young Enterprise Scheme and somehow, despite that experience, we both still decided public life was a good idea,”
on proposing Deputy Camp for election to the Policy & Resources Committee
0 votes (0%)
Guernsey
“So far I have changed my mind at least twice (Laughter) but I have come down to the view that I will be supporting this proposal for the arguments raised.”
“Rumours abound of a filibuster plan, so abound that it has been reported in the media. For those who do not know what filibustering is, it is just to waste time, to delay, (A Member: Hear, hear.) to fill the space for as long as you can.”
